Broward Sheriff’s Office arrests suspect who posed as a caregiver to steal from elderly residents in Deerfield Beach

Broward County, Florida – Broward County authorities have made a significant arrest in a case involving a suspect who posed as a caregiver to steal from elderly residents. Detectives with the Broward Sheriff’s Office (BSO) Deerfield Beach District identified and arrested 26-year-old Jamisha Shamari Sylvain after she allegedly defrauded several seniors, taking thousands of dollars from vulnerable victims. Officials say there may be additional victims and are urging anyone with information to come forward.

The case came to light in early October when BSO detectives received a report that an elderly man at the B’nai B’rith apartments in Deerfield Beach had been exploited by an unknown woman posing as a caregiver. According to the investigation, the victim allowed the woman into his apartment, where she gained access to his bank card. She reportedly withdrew money multiple times, totaling $1,600. Investigators quickly focused on Sylvain as the primary suspect in the case.

Further investigation revealed that Sylvain had allegedly committed similar crimes with other elderly residents. Detectives learned that she would present herself as a professional caregiver or claim to be newly assigned by the victim’s health insurance provider. Once inside the apartments, Sylvain would obtain debit cards and personal banking information from her victims. These tactics allowed her to systematically exploit elderly individuals, taking advantage of their trust and vulnerability.

Read also: Broward County reports steady job growth with 6,800 new nonagricultural positions added over the past year in September 2025

The arrest was the result of a coordinated effort involving several BSO units, including the Deerfield Beach District Criminal Investigations Unit (CI), the Deerfield Beach District Crime Suppression Team (CST), and the Deerfield Beach District Operational & Tactical Intelligence Center (OTIC). On Friday, December 19, Sylvain was located and taken into custody without incident. She was booked into the BSO Main Jail on multiple charges, including occupied burglary, elderly exploitation, criminal use of personal identification information, theft of credit card, and grand theft for victims 65 or older.

“This type of crime is particularly concerning because it targets some of our most vulnerable community members,” said a BSO spokesperson. Authorities are emphasizing the importance of vigilance and awareness to prevent such scams. They recommend confirming the identity, credentials, and references of caregivers before allowing anyone access to homes or finances.
Regularly monitoring financial accounts and involving a trusted family member or friend before sharing personal information can also help prevent exploitation.

BSO officials also encourage residents to report suspicious activity as soon as possible. Early reporting increases the likelihood that losses can be stopped and potential victims protected. Anyone who believes they or someone they know may have been targeted by a similar scam within a BSO jurisdiction is urged to contact the non-emergency line at 954-764-HELP (4357).

The investigation remains active, and detectives continue to follow leads to determine whether additional victims exist. Authorities stress that scams of this nature are often repeated, with perpetrators using confidence and deception to gain access to personal information and financial resources. In this case, Sylvain allegedly leveraged the trust that seniors place in caregivers, using false authority and persuasive tactics to commit her crimes.

Community members are being reminded to remain alert, particularly when unknown individuals claim to represent health care providers or agencies. Elderly residents are encouraged to verify appointments in advance and confirm that caregivers are legitimate and expected. Family members and caregivers are also advised to monitor unusual activity on accounts and maintain open communication with seniors about any unexpected requests for money or sensitive information.

Read also: West Palm Beach invites residents and visitors to ring in the New Year with Sandi Ferris wheel rides and a spectacular fireworks show

The arrest of Sylvain highlights the critical role law enforcement plays in protecting vulnerable populations. It also underscores the importance of community awareness in preventing fraud. With a concerted effort from both authorities and residents, scams targeting seniors can be minimized, ensuring that the elderly are able to feel safe and secure in their homes.

As the investigation continues, BSO detectives are asking anyone with additional information or concerns about similar incidents to come forward. By providing tips and information, residents can help protect the community and assist law enforcement in bringing perpetrators to justice. The agency stresses that even seemingly minor details can be instrumental in preventing further exploitation and safeguarding seniors from financial harm.